You Tried Motivation, Now Try This: Rethink Learning Through Gamification
.jpg)
Learn from gamification expert Valary Oleinik how game-based strategies can create more meaningful, motivating experiences for any program.Transcript below.
[02:57] Dave Asheim: Okay, well — My name is Dave. I'm the one on the left, Valerie is the one on the right, can you tell that? And, welcome to our 35, 45 minute, very active webinar. Hopefully this is going to be the highlight of your day. Make sure you have your cell phone handy. We're going to have you do a few things with your phone. We are recording this as well, and we'll send you a link to this and the slides, probably tomorrow morning. Anna, our marketing head, is in the background. Running the slides. I'll start it off, and then in a few minutes, we'll turn it over to Valerie, because it's really her show.
I run a company called Engage by Sell. If you're a client of ours, go ahead and put it in the chat window, and a yay for that. We're a U.S.-based company. I started this company 20 years ago. And, we're very big on customer support. Everything we do is a SaaS-based product, and in the next slide, you'll see what we — what we do. We have Many services, but the two main services. Are what you see on the screen, a text messaging service which can be used for everything from an announcement, to an event, to, Get your form submitted, to a little teaser, to a mobile web platform that we built about 10 years ago.
It's used for HR benefits, for training. A lot of museums use it for smartphone tours, anything you can imagine where you've got content that somebody might need access to. That's the place to put it. I am so excited to hear about Valerie's take on using gamification to motivate. I think all of us have a really hard time getting people to do what we want them to do, right, Valerie? Fill out the form. Come to the event, respond to my email, because you're not responding to my email. There's a million of these things, and I've always thought, and obviously Mallory does too, if you can make it entertaining, fun, game-like.
Not business-like all the time, you're going to have a lot more success with getting people to respond and engage, and I think that's why Valerie's world is about gamification, and she's here to tell you what she's learned. Everybody take out your phone, and scan that code. That just shows you how this texting can work. It'll open up your text message app. And it will say, Success Space Gamify, hit send. And then you'll be on our text message list, and Anna might push a few text messages to you just during today's webinar. It's kind of fun just to get some texts going, and then it'll also be a place where you can respond later with your email.
Alright, so — let's turn it over to, Valerie, and I'll hide my video, and then come back in, Valerie, when you're done.
[06:23] Valary: Okay, oh, you didn't have to go running off on my account, but okay.
[06:26] Dave Asheim: Oh, right, okay.
[06:27] Valary: But yeah, we're going to engage with you in a bunch of different ways today, so I hope you grab the QR code, that does give you access to, a handout I'll talk more about in just a minute, but you're going to want to have that, because what I want to leave you with today is not just some great ideas, hopefully. But something really practical that you can go back, Immediately. And you can try out in your space, and that's one of the first things we want to find out is, we have a poll on the screen, and I would like to know, just because I can — I can kind of — I can kind of, steer us a little bit, one way or another, based on — based on who you are and who's here today.
If you'd love to tell us what industry you work in, or industries — If you're like me, there's a bunch of boxes you could probably check there, right? Alright?
[07:19] Dave Asheim: Great.
[07:20] Valary: Someone will get.
[07:20] Dave Asheim: Okay.
[07:21] Valary: Moment, and then we'll — we get the magic reveal and find out who all's here today. I know where they're from. But what do they do? That'll be interesting. What do they do? The Pohl one. Alright. Isn't working. Oh, dear! Okay, well, we've got some answers coming in chat as well. Jody's in health. If you're having trouble with the poll, chat is free. I will not charge you anything. You can put as many answers in there.
[07:58] Dave Asheim: That's right.
[07:59] Valary: Too. It's always free of charge, and I'm going to encourage you to do a lot of chatting. Alright, did we — let's see, oh, there we go, we've got some customer service. I've been there, done that one. Real estate compliance. There's a — there's a — there's a fun word that actually gamification can help with. All right, there we go! There's the full results. Okay, so, oh, we got a — we got a cross-section of people. This is awesome.
[08:23] Dave Asheim: Wow.
[08:23] Valary: People in training, and.
[08:25] Dave Asheim: Yeah.
[08:25] Valary: And workforce, and other, and human resources, and tourism. I love it. I'm in New Orleans, so I — tourism is a big thing here. All right, thank you, and let's see, we've got — we've got some information. We had a second question about favorite game and why. So — we'll see — we'll see if we — if we — if we get some interesting answers there, and I'll explain why I asked that question in just a moment. I'm still looking at — back at the chat, see if anybody else — more compliance — yeah, lots — that's — that's obviously a big one.
You have lots of choices there. Alright. Alright. Okay — I'm not seeing the — I'm not seeing — I'm not seeing the game one yet, but if people answered it. If not, again, you can put your answers in the chat. And the reason I'm asking that one is, a lot of times when people — a lot of times people have kind of a misunderstanding of gamification, and what it is, and they think it's just, I want to make everything into a game, and that's not exactly That's not exactly true. So I'm going to go ahead and share my screen for one second, because I have yet another way for you to engage with me, and that is going to be, I have a little optional challenge that you can participate in.
So. On the screen, on this title slide, you might notice it's not a mistake. One of the letters has box around it. Now, if I were handing this — if I were giving you this slide deck in person, I would have some alt text on there to make this fully accessible for everybody. For today. I'm going to ask — we're going to crowdsource this. If you see a letter on any of my slides that has this gray box around it, I want somebody to throw it in the chat, because there's 10 letters that are going to be highlighted throughout the presentation, and if you spot them, write them down.
And unscramble them, it's going to be a two-word answer. All 10 letters are going to make 2 words, and they're going to tell you one of the suggestions I give people when they're beginning their gamification journey. Thank you! See, I knew — I knew this crowd, I knew you all would engage. And you all have identified the letter T, so keep watching, and share those as you see it. As long as at least one person gets it into the chat, everybody can benefit from that. Alright, and thank you, I saw some answers to some of the game things, and I love that.
Legend of Zelda, yeah, classics, awesome. And the reason I asked that question again is because people have this misunderstanding of Gamification. They also kind of have a misunderstanding of what to expect when I gamify something. People sometimes tell me I need a warning slide. Here's your warning. This is going to be different than most webinars. It's not going to just be me talking. As you saw, we already have a little challenge going. There's going to be lots of questions, and you all, I can tell, are already lighting this chat up, and that is Super awesome.
So — On this slide, we have one of the three words that people most often ask me about, or the reasons they come to me to work on gamification. And that's the word fun. Dave used it, I've used it, we've all used it. And fun is a part of it. But, the areas that gamification really shines, particularly in the spaces you all are in, is two other words. In the chat — Curious if you can tell me what — at least one of the other two main reasons people come to me and want to gamify things.
Can you come up with one of the words? Participation, that's good. Let's see what else we got. Any other suggestions? Lots of participation. Yeah, this — these — I'll tell you, neither of these words is actually on my screen right now. Engagement, Tom got — Tom got one of them. Ding, ding. These are all great answers, but yeah, Tom got one of them. Engagement. And one of them was in the title of the webinar today, and it's actually the main thing we're going to focus on today. I will talk about engagement some, but motivate! Yes, Dave, thank you!
Motivation, that is — Motivation and engagement are two things that Gamification shines in. And people come to me and want to talk about that for this very reason, and Dave alluded to it. Fill in the noun of your choice, all of my employees, my students, my staff, my clients, my customers, whatever word fits there for you. You swear that they're just all wearing this t-shirt. Highly motivated to do nothing. And that is not actually true. So one of the things I want to encourage us to think about today is reframing our discussion around motivation, because I think if we reframe it a little bit.
Some of the answers will be really powerful. What are some things that you can think of that look like somebody's not motivated, but might actually not really have anything to do with their motivation. What might be some challenges, some demotivating factors that you or your students or employees have encountered that might prevent them from appearing to be motivated. Anybody got any ideas on that one? Let's see, lack of training. Yes, they don't know what to do. That's a big one. Business, bandwidth, yes, these are all things. Now, some of these things don't understand why they're being asked to do it, absolutely.
All of these are excellent answers. And I would say, a few of them that I often get, and I have shared with people, are some of these. And some of these, we can fix with gamification. Some of them, we can't. If your office is too cold, or your chair is lumpy, and you're uncomfortable, I can't fix that one with gamification. But, as some of you alluded to. If I just don't know what to do, I'm stuck. I don't know what to do. I'm confused. I'm bored. These are things, they think they already know everything. Oh my goodness, Deborah, I have worked with those people.
Those are, those are challenging, but even, even the hardest, participants can be won over quite often. But that's the first thing I want to think about, is actually when we say people aren't motivated, we are actually, in most cases, saying they're not motivated to do what we want them to do. It's not that they're not motivated, it's just — They're not directing their energy the way we want them to. So — We think, well, if we could just motivate them. And again, we might have tried that, and the whole carrot and stick, and we offer them bonuses and rewards, and — We do all those things, and those things are just not really working long-term either.
And we're going to — we're going to dive into that in just a moment. But — Years ago, I came across this quote. I'll give you a moment to look at it. It's by Edward DC, and we're going to talk about him more in a minute. But it really — it was kind of one of those Rubik's Cube moments where I went, that's a different way of looking, reframing the idea. It's not about me motivating people. It's about what conditions I create. So it's about design choices. And so, that is something I can control if I'm designing training, or a product, or a service, or whatever my space is.
And in fact, that handout that they gave you the QR code for it at the beginning, it actually has 30 questions, that you can dive into later. And they're segments, and it's really the same 30 questions, but I kind of framed them for both those of you who are in the learning and development space. And those of you who are more on the business operation and business development side, and I just reworded them a little bit. But it's really the same 30 questions, and those are the ones I'm encouraging you after this to go back, just look through, and pick one or two from each category, and see how they might apply with this idea in mind, that you're creating the conditions for people to be motivated.
So that's — that's the first little sort of tweak that I think we can make to our motivation conversation. Now, the next thing is, I want to introduce you to three of my friends. This is Roberta, Marwin, and Stanley. And thank you, Michelle was the first one to hop in there with an S. Yes, your tag, your — flag in those letters, that's great. So these three actually are not real people. They're kind of real to me, because I created them. They're personas. Let me know in the chat, have any of you used the concept of personas in your work before?
Learner persona, marketing personas. Anything, or is this concept new? I hope it's new to some of us, because that's — that's always fun, too. No, thank you, Jody. Yes, okay, we have some — we have some — we have some yeses, we have some nos, yeah, in marketing, there you go. Well. Whatever your space is, if you are designing for other people, which presumably you all are, based on what I know so far, a persona is just a collection of attributes around a portion of your population. This does not — Roberta is not a description of a particular person.
Roberta, and I only gave you the little, like. Snippet of the intro of the prompt that we could, like, build out to decide who Roberta is. But Roberta is not an actual person, she is a collection of concepts that adequately, or somewhat adequately describe a portion of your audience. And the reason that we do this, and it's so incredibly powerful, is that it shifts how you design things. So if you're designing learning, you stop designing for content. And you start designing for the human who's going to be using the content. When you start to put a name and a face to, oh, wow, how, if you're designing something and you start to think, well, hmm.
How would that work for Stanley? Like, okay, well, Stanley's in his car a lot, he's traveling, like, would that work? You really start to make different design choices. So we're not going to go into a whole big persona activity today, but there's a lot of information out there about it. I'm happy to answer questions later. Particularly this started more in the marketing side of things, so Google, you'll find lots of stuff. And little templates, there's a lot of good templates out there. But you start to ask yourself questions like these, and — So just think about your audience.
You may know them. Because they may be your employees, but sometimes, like today, I didn't know before I got here what industries you all would be in, what your interests necessarily would be, but you're going to see in a moment, I could make some choices that I am really sure will resonate with most of you. And we'll hopefully create a condition where you all get motivated to go try out some of these things. Now, of the questions on the screen right now, the one that I really like to draw people's attention to is what assumptions are you making?
So I'm going to go back to our screen a moment ago, and we're going to talk about Stanley for a second. So I only gave you a couple of little snippets about Stanley, but what are some of the assumptions that you might make about Stanley that would influence how you interact with him. What are some things that, just based on that limited amount of information, what might you think about Stanley? See what we come up with. Anybody — He's highly experienced, thank you, thank you, highly experienced in sales, that's good to know. He's tired. That's probably true.
Doesn't want to be away from home, right? He wants stability. Okay, so all of these things, they're very different than if I just said, Stanley is a member of a demographic that he's between 50 and 65, right? That's — that's, you know. I don't know how old he is, but that is one of the assumptions. It's interesting, none of you — I love — I love that none of you said this, but, the first one that I often get in workshops is, he's old. I didn't say anything in there that says he's old. Just because it says he has twin grandsons?
Like, doesn't mean he's old. There's a lot of — we could make his story be a lot of different things. I also said that he had machine part sales. I didn't say what kind of machines they were, and a lot of times people will be like, oh, he might have trouble working on a computer. Like, I didn't say what kind of machine it was. He might — they might be machine parts for robotics. They might be something really technical, like — But again, when you start to break these things down and build out these personas, that's where some of these things bubble up, and you start to go, wow, what assumptions am I making about my staff or about my students?
And — how might I want to adjust how I design things for them? So — I will leave that there for now, but hopefully it does start to get you thinking. And it's also important, and like I said, I ask these kinds of questions to people sometimes when they're designing stuff, how would they learn something on their own, because again. Different people are not only motivated by different things, but they might be motivated by different things at different times, in different contexts, and so the more we can humanize the design of things, it really, it really makes a huge difference.
So — Moving into our core content for today. Do not run away, because I use the word theory. It's okay. We're not going to get too technical here, I promise. But one of the core elements that we talk about in the world of gamification quite often is self-determination theory. And I like to start people here. For a couple of reasons. Many of you were in the workforce space, or HR, and places like that, and when you first go and start trying to pitch ideas, and you start throwing words around like gamification, quite often you get some pushback.
Now, I don't always use the word gamification when I'm telling somebody about what we're designing, but If that word comes up, some people, oh, we don't, we don't play games here. And they want proof. Senior management wants proof, like, is this going to work? Like, is there any, is there any science behind this? Is there any research behind this? That's why I'm taking just a quick moment To mention a few things here, because sometimes you may encounter that you — to get the buy-in, you need to kind of Let them know, yeah, this is — this is a real thing, and it has some real power to it.
All right, so self-determination theory, again, has a long history, so it's not something we just made up, it's not something that just started, but it does have three main components, and I am oversimplifying. If anybody is in the psychology space, I apologize. I'm going to oversimplify a bit today. But when DC and Ryan were studying, they were trying to determine, was it better to have intrinsic motivation, or sort of the fire within you. Or extrinsic motivation, which you could kind of think of as, like, the fire underneath you, I guess. And intrinsic motivation. Proves to be more long-standing.
And so, especially in workforce things and in learning, if you can sustain the interest, if you can get people to be motivated based on their own values, their own interest in it. It's a much easier — it's a much easier thing to get them to participate in. And yay, Kerry loves self-determination theory. See? It's — there's a lot to love in there. There is a lot to love in there. But the gamification world, we definitely hang on to it, and we've only been around — the word gamification actually is only 15 years old, so it's like a little baby, like, compared to some of these other things.
But we're going to talk about each of these three main elements very quickly. And again, this is what that handout gives you, is 10 questions based on each of these that you can go and pick one or two to try out later. But — Just to briefly explain, so we've got our autonomy, which is just people like to have choice. They like to have volition over what they're doing, some agency. These are adult — all of you, I believe, or most of you are working with adults, and they don't want to be told what to do all the time.
They want to have some options. Competence. Obviously, we all want to feel good in that we know what we're doing. That's an important component. And then relatedness ties to our social belonging and community sort of things. We're going to look at a couple of very quick examples of each. And — moving along. As far as autonomy goes. Couple ways you can do this. One of my favorite ways is to give people choice. If you can let people set their own goals, choose their own adventure, I don't know if any of you remember those books. The Choose Your Own Adventure books, you'd be reading, and it would say, if you want to do this, go to page 5.
If you want to do this, go to page 14. Forcing people to go through everything in a linear fashion is far less motivating than letting them explore. So sometimes it's as simple as that. It's as simple as just letting them explore more. That's a huge, gainful element. An example from the world of technical training. Years ago, I was teaching Excel. And, we decided, I was playing one of those little casual games, you've probably played them, and, like, each level, you get 1, 2, or 3 stars, and at first, you're like, oh, I need 3 stars on everything.
Or if you're — if you're — if that's your personality. And, then I was like, why? Why do I need 3 stars on everything? I really don't. It's — it's a game, it doesn't matter. But I carried that over into the training. In our training, we had 5 modules. And so Module 1 was core content. And so we said, everybody has to complete all four activities in Module 1 to complete the training. But, in the other four modules, we're going to give them some choice. So they had to pick one other module, in this case it was Module 4, And they have to do all the activities in that module.
But maybe all of the stuff isn't applicable to their role right now. They just have to end up having completed 15 of the 20 total. See? Very simple way, we let people pick and choose a little bit. If they needed to go back and learn the other content later, they had already been exposed to it. They would — they would be able to go back and do the other modules they hadn't completed before, but this way, they felt like, okay, this is relevant to me, I only have to do the stuff that's super important to me right now.
Okay, so that's just a little — quick way, that you might employ something, like choice in a design process. Very easy, very quick to do. Another way would be to choose how they interact with you. This is a huge one. Obviously, with products and services nowadays, you might have a chatbot, or maybe there's a phone line, or there's an email, or different ways to do it. I work a lot with global audiences, and when I work with higher ed, a lot of non-traditional students. English not always the first language. And so, asking people to always go through training or go through certain things in the same way.
Adds a level of cognitive load and difficulty that is just not necessary. And so I sometimes share, I don't know if anybody ever watched the show Modern Family? In the show, her character is often made fun of because her English, she doesn't quite get the idioms right, miss, says things what appears to be a little comically. But this moment on this show was so poignant, and I pulled this up in a workshop one time, and the person who had scheduled it, English was not their first language, and they came over afterwards and thanked me. And said, you have no idea how difficult it is to constantly be translating.
In my head, everything. So again, this is just one way that you could choose how people interact with you, but this one, is a very powerful one, so I just — I like to — I like to include that one. So that's just a couple of brief, things on autonomy. All right, moving into competence, and I know you all highly competent, and you want to make sure your staff and everybody are competent. A couple of tips there. This one, yes, this one we have two letters. One way is just mapping out clear pathways. Some of you said at the beginning, when I said, what is demotivating for people?
They don't know what to do. They don't know where to go. A lot of gamification systems you'll find have some sort of map, some sort of, graphic that helps people sort of navigate where they're going. It also lets them see how far they've progressed. It's also a progress marker in some ways. So anytime you can add something that makes it clear, because a lot of times that is what people — what causes people to stop, they're just not clear. They get stuck. And when people get stuck, they stop. It's really hard to get somebody going again.
But if they can see, and especially if there's alternate pathways, like we talked about a moment ago, okay, maybe you're really not — you're not having a good time doing this one pathway, maybe if you give them another alternative. It gets them back on track. So that's one way that you can build competence into your — into your programs, in an interesting way. If you're doing products or services, obviously, if I — if I bought a new camera. And I open the box, maybe there's two QR codes. Maybe if I'm an expert, I get a QR code that takes me right into a community of other people who are using this camera and already know how to do all that stuff, do all the photography stuff.
Maybe there's another code that says, hey, if you're just getting started. Here's a QR code that takes you to a little tutorial. And then you drip out, letting them — letting them do something like that. Do the same thing with onboarding and various types of training. All right. As I'm going along, if anything I say, you have a question, a comment, go right ahead and keep those coming in. We'll have time for questions in just a second. Now, another thing that games do really powerfully, and since a lot of you are in the education and training space, if you've played Candy Crush, and you're among friends, you can admit it's okay.
If you've played Candy Crush, you know there's certain levels. And you play them over and over and over, and they're so hard! And you're just like, oh, I'm never going to get past this level. But you keep playing. And that's the beauty of games, is that as long as people feel that there's a chance that they can get better at it, there's a chance that they could pass the level, we keep trying. So it's not that failing is a bad thing, and that's one of the things that gameplay really is good at talking about, and that's a little bit of a rabbit hole for another day.
But I do want to mention this here, because if you've played those games, and then the next level, right after that really hard one. What happens? The next one is super easy. That is by design. That is not your imagination. That is just how they design them. And the reason for that is they want to keep you playing. They want to keep you playing. And so, there's flow theory. And basically, if things are too easy, we get bored and stop. If things are too hard. We just — we just can't do it, we can't deal with it, anxiety.
And so games, good games anyway, keep us right in that flow zone. We get challenged. And then we have a little rest period, and then we get challenged, and we have a little rest period. And I think that's something that we sometimes overlook when we're designing, particularly training and educational things. We think that it's like this steep uphill climb, and we have to just keep making harder and harder and harder and harder. No! Give them a little moment to rest and regroup in between. You will find that will also sort of reset the motivation of, oh, yeah, look how far I've come.
That stuff that used to be really hard. It's not so hard anymore! And that's a really powerful motivator for a lot of people as they're — as they're building competence in things. Another little quick tip to consider. And then finally, on competence, anytime you can provide calls to action, self-monitoring, whether that's a checklist, whether that is they're collecting things, collections is a game element that's used for this a lot, progress bars. Things that you can do to help people track their progress. As long as people see — there's a book called The Progress Principle. That is what's motivating to people, even in very difficult jobs.
Like, as long as they can see that their manager is, helping them to make some meaningful progress over time, the bad days are bad days, but they're not, like, overwhelming at that point. And anybody who, like, I wear — I wear a wearable thing, anybody who's ever done that knows there's a difference between saying, I'm going for a walk. And seeing the numbers. When you can provide those ways for them to self-monitor, again. Big gains. Big gains in keeping people motivated. All right, and thank you all are doing great with your letters. You probably can start to unscramble the letters a little bit by this point.
Remember, it's two — it's going to be two words in the answer. All right. Finally, we're almost done. Relatedness. You have — in many games, you have a guide on the side, or some sort of community aspect, and this is something that I think is way underutilized in a lot of — in a lot of settings. We often have, like, a community space or something, but it's not always — fully integrated, it's not always used as much as people want it to be used. In games, I often get a lot of ideas from different options.
In this game, there actually was an actual character that was a guide. And I will tell you, as far as relatedness, it doesn't have to be a real person all the time. Storytelling is super powerful. The brain does not — the brain does not react differently to me actually doing something, and me playing the game or reading a story about somebody else. The brain processes those activities very similarly. In the game, I can have her in my training, I can have a character who's my guide. It doesn't always have to be a physical person, but again, the more of these human connections we can build into it.
The more motivating, especially if the character in the story is someone that maybe the person you're training is helping. The character could be someone helping the trainee, or it could be something that the trainee is learning how to help this person. Both of those are very powerful motivators. Another game that does something kind of interesting and different. This one had sort of a Facebook-type feed built into the game. So the characters in the game would be sending messages, but if you were connected to your friends in the game space, you could also, like, have your own messages in there.
So again, the use of story, the use of characters. Super powerful. Very different experience for me to teach somebody how to click buttons to fill out a form for a process, or me creating an experience for someone where Maria called you, and she's having — we had a customer service person I know, in the list today. Maria called your customer service center with a — with a problem today. She doesn't understand how to fill out the form. Now I've created an entire environment. And I've created a space where the employee can now feel some ownership and some connection, because they're helping Maria!
Like, it's not just, I'm filling out a form. Again, another super powerful thing for creating those motivation spaces. So hopefully, by now, something, some little, some little thing I said today, hopefully, will help you think about ways that you can help your people to be highly motivated to do more than they were doing before. They're no longer highly motivated to do nothing. And with that, I will give you your last letter. To complete the 10-letter collection. And oh my gosh, Bonnie! She just, like, she got right in there first. She — sorry, Kathryn, she kinda — she typed a little bit faster today.
But thank you, thank you all for playing along. That is so awesome! I know, sorry, Kathryn, but you both win. You can — we — everybody wins. Everybody wins, because hopefully you learned something today that you can use. Like I said, my goal is not just that you come and have some fun and hopefully enjoy the last half hour, but more importantly, for me. Is that you took something away that you can use, and I have my email on the screen, you can connect with me on LinkedIn as well. If you have more questions, I can take some now, I think we have time, but If you want to connect and talk more later, I am certainly happy to talk with any of you, and thank you all so much for your participation and — and getting those answers in there.
I'm going to stop sharing and bring Dave back in.
[38:47] Dave Asheim: That was great, Valerie, and start small. I didn't have start small, I had — You did! I had words that really didn't make any sense, so
[38:57] Valary: Yeah, I tell people, think big — the whole phrase usually is, think big, but start small. You don't have to do —
[39:04] Dave Asheim: Yo.
[39:04] Valary: You don't have to do it all at once. Go try something. Just go try something.
[39:08] Dave Asheim: We've got a few more minutes, everybody, so in the chat window, this is your chance to ask Valerie, our expert. I wrote down 3 or 4 questions. I'll start. Okay. Valerie. Some people, you mentioned the word community, you mentioned the word game, it's shut down, I don't want to do it, although deep down. They do like both of those. Yes. You must face that all the time. So how does, one of our — one of our participants sell it up and sell it to their audience when it's an immediate, I don't want to do it?
[39:44] Valary: Yeah, oh my gosh, and I've totally, I've totally designed for things like that. I think, I think a couple of things you can do. One is, you always want to have multiple pathways for them. Maybe they don't want to play the game. But maybe they do want to show how smart they are in the community. I've had many of those, like, I don't play games, but then they want to go and, like. Tell everybody all the information they learned, so you know they were learning it. So as long as you — because again, different people are going to respond to different types of — types of things.
So that's one tip, is you're never going to — you're never going to build something that just has, like, a leaderboard. Like, I don't want.
[40:25] Dave Asheim: Right.
[40:25] Valary: Leaderboard, then I don't want to play. Generally, I try to make it so that the gameplay is optional. It depends on the situation. Okay. Sometimes that's — sometimes that's more or less, and that's kind of controversial. Some people are like, no, you shouldn't — you shouldn't give them an opt-out. Sometimes there's some legitimate reasons for it. So I'm like, I'm — I'm not going to be — I'm not going to be a snob about it and be like, you have to play my game. Another thing that's really powerful And there's a really good example from years ago I could go dig up.
Using other people, using — finding some champions, finding some people who are really enjoying it. And leveraging that, and getting them to go and bring the people in. Or creating activities within your system that people need other people for. Yeah. Like, you can't complete this activity by yourself. Maybe you don't have all the pieces to the puzzle. Usually then, especially with, hopefully, if you — if — now, if you have — if you have a team that's not working well together, that's — that's a symptom that you should be addressing. If people don't want to play together.
Like, that's something to be looking at, and that's something that actually comes up a lot with people who, I have a colleague who is an expert at designing escape rooms, and he always says, I'm less interested in them, like, completing the escape room, I want to see how their dynamic is. I want to see how they work together. Leverage other people. Yeah. Find your champions, find who it is. So I think that's two ways — two ways that work really well.
[42:13] Dave Asheim: What about partnering one of those people with another person that.
[42:16] Valary: Yeah.
[42:16] Dave Asheim: That feels a little bit more comfortable. That's another.
[42:19] Valary: Absolutely. Yeah, it's, it's, it's, and again, it depends on the system. I had, I had a course years ago, and we had them go through in cohorts, and we would have, the first cohort left messages. For the next group. Like, incarnate little poses — we call.
[42:38] Dave Asheim: It was interesting.
[42:39] Valary: Had a space theme, so we called it Postcards from Space.
[42:42] Dave Asheim: And so.
[42:43] Valary: Like, they had somebody who had already been through the experience. And so, like, that was a contact point. And then we built in activities where, yes, they had to go talk to their manager, or they had to talk to, yes, very Elder Scrolls. You had to, you had to do some activities together, and then some activities by yourself, so that we kind of — The whole point was, you want to create whatever you're creating, and this is, this is the key thing, It needs to serve the purpose. Of what you're doing. Like, a lot of times, people are — maybe they're like, the problem, or part of the underlying problem, is that their team is not functioning well together.
And then they create a gamification system that's based on competition. I'm like, that doesn't go together.
[43:31] Dave Asheim: You have now.
[43:31] Valary: Taken that team and made it more fragmented, because you're going to have some of them that are going to be super competitive, and, that's not going to work well. Like, it has to all fit together, whatever, whatever gameful elements you're using. Yeah, I'd want to build some collaborative some ways for them to collaborate in a — Yeah. Yeah.
[43:52] Dave Asheim: Yep. Your flow zone, I thought that was so interesting, not knowing gamification like you do, I had never heard of that concept, but it's — it's such an — such a natural idea. Is the flow zone the same, then, for everybody that's in the group? Progressing through, or some people's flow zone are going to be a little different, or how do you — how do you handle that?
[44:15] Valary: That's a — well, what I would — one way you can handle it, depending on — depending — again. Each thing is unique, obviously. I like to use, like, little side quest type things. Like, I want the core content to kind of get everybody, keep everybody kind of, like, moving through it. This also helps when you have people that have very different experience levels, because you have some people that just fly through the whole thing, and then you have other people that are just, like, just starting, like, and that doesn't work well. And then you don't want to lock everything down, because then the people who finish the module, like, in 5 minutes, they're sitting there.
For a week, waiting for something to happen, and then they're completely demotivated by then. One way you can do it is you can — you can build for the core piece. Sort of, built for that. And again, you want to, you want to kind of just — the pacing of it and the difficulty of it, you want to kind of vary it, to maintain interest of everybody. But you can build off side quests, so if somebody really is experienced, or just really gets interested in something, let them — let them — give them somewhere to go.
Give them somewhere to explore that — doesn't — that doesn't mess up, like, it's not — it's not like, oh, I'm going to teach them this stuff that everybody should have known. Like, it has to be something special. Or, a lot of times you can build that into reward structures. Maybe, like, if it's a management training program or something, maybe if somebody has really excelled and they're moving very quickly through things, you don't want them to lose momentum, you don't want to lose them, maybe there's — maybe there's, like, a lunch meeting or something that you can invite them to so that they can start to meet some of the other team members in another group or something.
Right. So you can reward them in a way that is meaningful, because that's the other thing. You want these things to have meaning. You never want to just throw game elements at something, just for the fun's sake.
[46:19] Dave Asheim: Yeah. It's okay.
[46:20] Valary: To be fun, but it has to have some meaning to them. It's like, it's like points. What do points mean? The points don't mean anything unless they're tied to something that means something.
[46:31] Dave Asheim: Is that because the participants will see through that, and eventually just say, why am I wasting my time playing this silly little game? It's not helping me professionally.
[46:39] Valary: Exactly. It's not helping them, it's a — yeah, they'll feel like it's a waste of time, it'll feel cheesier, but if it has some meaning, it has to have some — it has to have some meaning to it, and then — and then it's fine. Then, nothing against points are great, so — We need to count things somehow.
[46:57] Dave Asheim: You would, of course, love everybody to connect with you on LinkedIn, and Anna will send that information. If some of the folks that are on the call here today want to get in touch with you because they might want to use your services, your consulting, your brain, just bouncing ideas, I'm guessing you just welcome any and all people to reach out and just say.
[47:22] Valary: I do! I'd love to.
[47:23] Dave Asheim: To talk to you, so everybody on the call, take Valerie up on that. She is one of the experts in the country, so you have an opportunity to really dig deep, and, maybe there'll be something that Can be long-term with that, too, or can just be just meet her.
[47:41] Valary: I was going to say, it can be — it can be — it can be whatever it needs to be. You — anybody who emails me, you'll see in my signature line my scheduler to book a call, and I do have — I do have the option for those who do want to work with me, I do have, called Power Hour, because pick my brain just hurts. That, that, I don't want people picking on me. No, don't do that. But, so there's, there's, there's, there's many ways, but yeah, just either LinkedIn's the fastest, probably, and, we'll get going from there.
[48:11] Dave Asheim: Okay, and Anna will send everybody probably a text, and you can reply with her email, just to make sure that we have your email, or if there are others in your organization that would like it, put that in the text. And, we'll get the recording to you tomorrow, and thank you, Valerie, and thank you, everybody, for attending a super session here on this Wednesday afternoon.
[48:33] Valary: Thanks, everybody.
[48:34] Dave Asheim: Alright, bye everybody!
%20(1).png)


